Lady May Coffee-Infused Tallow Eye Cream – Brighten, Firm & Revitalize Naturally

Name: Lady May Coffee-Infused Tallow Eye Cream – Brighten, Firm & Revitalize Naturally
Brand: Lady May Tallow
SKU: TALLOW-2-EYECREAM
Rating: 4.91 (902 reviews)

Coffee-Infused Tallow Eye Cream

A rich, nourishing eye cream made with grass-fed beef tallow, cold-pressed jojoba oil, and coffee bean extract. Coffee's natural caffeine helps de-puff and brighten, while tallow and jojoba lock in moisture — leaving delicate under-eye skin soft, smooth, and refreshed.

Benefits:

De-puffs and brightens tired eyes
Deeply hydrating, non-greasy
Rich in vitamins A, D, E, K
Smooths fine lines
Gentle, preservative-free, safe for sensitive skin

2oz glass jar. Handmade in the USA. Tip: store in the fridge for extra de-puffing

Complete Your Eye Care Routine

Maximize results by pairing with:

Unscented Whipped Tallow - Use on rest of face after applying eye cream
Tallow Cleansing Balm - Gentle enough to remove eye makeup
Tallow Balm - Extra moisture for very dry under-eyes

Get it in a set: Vanilla Gift Set or Lavender Gift Set

Pro tip: Keep in the fridge for extra de-puffing power!

Our Ingredients — Transparency You Can Trust

We use only premium essential oils from Berjé Inc. (a 75+ year, third-generation family-owned leader) and the finest carrier oils in every product we make. Want to know exactly what goes into your skincare?

→ Explore Our Full Ingredient Guide — Learn about every essential oil and carrier oil we use, why we chose them, and how they benefit your skin.

Product variants

Unique Features & Benefits

Sustainable Farming: We partner with farms that prioritize animal welfare and environmental stewardship, promoting a healthier planet.
Small Batch Production: Each batch is carefully monitored to maintain consistency and exceptional quality.
Wet Rendered: This traditional method preserves the tallow's natural nutrients and flavor, making it a superior choice for various applications.

OUR PROMISE

We want our customers happy! Our promise is to provide you with the best tallow products or your money back!

100% Satisfaction Guarantee

Fast USA Shipping

ALWAYS 100% Natural Ingredients

Guarantees

Thoughtfully Sourced Tallow

We use high-quality tallow from U.S.-raised cattle, including grass-fed sources, to create every Lady May Tallow product.
Natural Oils & Ingredients

Our essential oils, seed oils, and additional ingredents are always natural and safe for your skin.
Money Back Guarantee

We pride ourselves in delivering premium tallow products. If you don't love your product, message us and we will make it right!
Fast Shipping

Get your products fast! Our ship times are 1-2 business days after your order is placed.

Tallow FAQs

What is tallow?

Tallow has been used for centuries in skincare. With bioavailable vitamins A, B12, D, E, K, and various fatty acids, tallow helps soften, moisturize, and revitalize the skin.

Do your products have a "beefy" scent?

We get this question all the time and while it is very valid, the answer is no!

We use a wet-rendering process for all of our tallow products. This completely purifies the tallow, leaving it odorless, while maintaining the key nutrients and benefits for your skin!

How much tallow should I use?

A little goes a long way with our tallow products. Start by using the size of a penny and see if you need more! Tallow will soak into your skin and leave your skin barrier deeply moisturized.

How should I store my tallow products?

Store your moisturizer away from light and drastic temperature changes.

To maintain its original texture, store your moisturizer in a typical temperature-controlled environment (68-74 degrees). Extreme temperatures can cause the tallow to harden in cold conditions or melt in warm conditions. If this occurs, there's no need to worry; the moisturizer is still usable, but know the texture may change.

Can I use tallow if I have oily skin?

Yes! When the skin is excessively cleansed and stripped of its natural oils, it tends to overproduce oil. Using a high-quality moisturizer, like whipped tallow, can help maintain skin's moisture balance and prevent excess oil production.

Can I use tallow if I have acne-prone skin?

Yes! The antimicrobial, anti-inflammatory, and skin-repairing qualities of tallow can greatly benefit acne-prone skin.

What are the uses for tallow skincare?

There are many uses for your tallow skincare products.

Our products can be used for moisturizing the skin (face & body), diaper rashes, and eczema/other skin irritations.

Is this product organic?

Our tallow boasts a clean label with no artificial ingredients. However, it is not certified organic.

What part of the cow does the fat come from? Is it suet?

The fat we use primarily comes from the kidney area and loins of the cow. This specific type of fat is known as suet, prized for its purity and quality. Our "nose-to-tail sustainable farms" ensure that no fat goes to waste, utilizing all parts of the animal for their unique benefits for a premium blend of beef tallow.

Are the farms sustainable?

Yes, the farms we partner with focus on ethical practices that respect both the land and the animals. Every batch of our tallow carries the promise of sustainability and a nod to generations past.

Does this product need to be refrigerated?

No, the product is shelf-stable at room temperature. However, you can refrigerate or freeze it if you wish to extend the shelf life. Refrigeration will make the product harder, but many bakers prefer this consistency for creating flakier crusts.

5 stars: 864 (96%)
4 stars: 19 (2%)
3 stars: 7 (1%)
2 stars: 3 (0%)
1 star: 9 (1%)

3 Stars

I like the product itself — it works well and does what it's supposed to do. Unfortunately, the shipping experience was not great. The eye cream I bought leaked all over the packaging material, making quite a mess when I opened the box.
I reached out to customer service several times to let them know what happened and ask for help, but I never received any response. That lack of communication was really disappointing.
If you're considering buying, just be aware that while the product is decent, the customer service and shipping quality could use some improvement.

Melanie — this is Chris, the owner of Lady May. I just read your review and I'm so sorry. The eye cream leaking all over the packaging material when it arrived is absolutely not okay, and I'm even more sorry you reached out multiple times and heard nothing back. We've been going through a staffing transition on customer service for the past few months, and your messages got lost in the shuffle. That's my fault as the owner, not just a CS issue. I'm making this right. You'll be hearing from us shortly about a replacement. And if there's anything else you need, please reach out directly at cmcdonald@aintlifegrandinvestments.com. — Chris

love it

love it .. works !

Felt amazing on my skin.

I made the mistake of not using tallow for a while, I decided to make the switch back when I got tired of researching all ingredients in “natural” skincare products to make sure they are “pregnancy safe”. I love these tallow products they do exactly what they claim to do, I recommend them to all my friends and family!! They even sent me a beautiful care package when I became pregnant!

My second time buying and I love it!! Will definitely continue being a repeat customer! Super fast shipping and the quality is fantastic

Oh my goodness - the SMELL!!! It is so unbelievably amazing, I can't get enough! It's so soothing, so hydrating, and seriously just smells so freaking good!! Worth every penny. I will definitely be buying more. Already love this shop and I just got their products for the first time. So glad I did! Literally can't praise these products enough. So good!!!

Absolutely LOVE the coffee tallow eye cream. It smells amazing & really moisturizes. If you love the smell of coffee you’ll love this product. Highly recommend.

2nd Order

My 2nd order of 2 coffee infused eye cream arrived. I am happy. I use it not only under eyes but for my face as well. It gives a nice glow to my face and my skin loves it.
Those will last several month.
I also use whipped tallow for body.
Been cooking with their tallow as well.
The only fact I feel sorry about is I've got to know about lady may tallow so late means about a year or so ago.

This and the vanilla tallow are my two favorite scents!!! A little bit of the product really does go a long way! I personally use this eye cream all over my face … and I’m talking a pea size and a half at most covers the whole face when face is slightly damp. Keeps the area moisturized all day! Not greasy either.

I’ve been happily using the whipped tallow for a few years now and I decided to try some new products. This product is just as amazing as the others I’ve tried.

The tallow itself has a nice coffee scent...

The tallow itself has a nice coffee scent with a fluffy texture! Overall really pleased, however, I did deduct one star due to it coming with chipped/cracked glass on the bottom of the container that I ended up cutting my finger on while trying to open it. Other than that the product is exactly as expected!

So in love with this! Smells incredible an...

So in love with this! Smells incredible and just melted into my skin.

First of all, I love the smell of coffee!...

First of all, I love the smell of coffee! In skincare, I can't even begin to describe. This stuff smells so delicious, looks beautiful and feels amazing. You really don't need a crazy amount of product for the eyes …

This smells soooo good! It's a small jar b...

This smells soooo good! It's a small jar but a little goes a long way! I haven't used an eye cream
In a while and excited to try this one out

I am obsessed! I apply in the AM and PM, i...

I am obsessed! I apply in the AM and PM, it has helped reduce my puffy morning eyes and has helped reduce my dark circles. It also smells amazing!

Great seller, loved the body whipped tallo...

Great seller, loved the body whipped tallow. Giving the eye tallow a try, so far love the hydration.

I love this eye cream and the smell is ama...

I love this eye cream and the smell is amazing. The only concern I had was it was delivered Oct 19 and on the label it said Expires 11.24 so that means I have about a month to use it? There's a lot in this 2oz jar so I was hoping to use it for 6+ months… I'm wondering if maybe this was an old batch? I wish I got a new batch that expired in 2025… but nonetheless, I really do love all their skincare products especially this eye cream. Thank you

Update: They responded back and said they bought the labels in bulk and didn't realize it said EXP 11/24 but reassured me that it's made freshly and will last 12 months.

This stuff is the best!!! A little goes such a long way

This stuff is the best!!! A little goes such a long way. Makes my skin look amazing.

Love this cream!

I’ve been using this eye cream for a couple of years now and I absolutely love it. The texture, the smell. I use it every night and sometimes I just slather it on my whole face. My skin has never felt better and I do feel like it has helped the aging skin around my eyes.

Love this product, works wonders on dark circles!

I placed this order from a YouTubers 5* rant!
The 3 products do not disappoint!!
I’m excited to see if all 3 products will help with my extremely dry skin…
Thank you for the bonus gift! I can now keep a lip treatment in 2 places!!